Wednesday, September 25, 2013

On "Reinventing the Wheel"

I decided to name my blog "Reinventing the Wheel" because it is a phrase I have heard often upon entering the teaching community. Usually, the conversation goes something like:


Frustrated and tired Teacher Candidate:  "Ugh, I don't know about this lesson! Will this engage the students enough? Do I incorporate different methods of learning and instruction? How will I assess their learning in a  measurable  and meaningful way?"

Savvy Veteran Teacher: "Dont worry about it, kid! You will do great! Its not like you are reinventing the wheel."


What does this phrase mean exactly? Dictionary.com suggests that this figure of speech means "to make unnecessary or redundant preparations".  The general feeling of the phrase is that there is nothing new or original to be done, and it is usually said in a derisive manner. It falls under the category of phrases like "If it ain't broke, don't fix it." Basically at it's core is the belief that there is nothing to be improved upon. Any "new" or "fascinating insight" you bring has already been done before. So why try?

When should the wheel be reinvented? That is really a tough question. The following are some examples of times when it might be the right move:

* When something obviously needs improvement. Maybe it was great at one time, but it doesn't currently meet the need or help accomplish the mission in the most efficient and effective manner. 
* When someone has an idea that might improve it (whatever "it" is), even if it is working. If the improvement helps make it better, cheaper, easier to use or maintain, or improves the efficiency, why not use the idea?
* When someone has a new and innovative idea. If the idea will lead to a better product or process of some kind that is needed or useful, reinvention may be worthwhile.
* When the dollar and time constraints aren't there. This doesn't happen often, but it is in the realm of possibility.  
(adapted from "Two sides of reinventing the wheel."Defense Acquisition University Press. thefreelibrary.com)

With respect to technology in education, I think it is about time to "reinvent the wheel." The education system clearly could use some revamping/reimagining. Maybe the old system once worked, but in this day and age its not properly preparing our students for the rapidly changing future. Even though there are successes in the education system, why not implement technology to help potentially make the system better, easier to use, and more efficient? This acceptance and experimental phase may lead to even greater advancements and outcomes that we might not even be able to conceive at this moment in time. Although technology devices cost quite a bit up front, the cost of brick and mortar tools/devices are just as costly. In other arenas the price of using technology is very little and might help to lower the overall cost of education.

Therefore, the goal of this blog is to explore the ins and outs, the ups and downs, the pros and cons of technology in education, in order to see if we can really reinvent the wheel.

3 comments:

  1. Hi Caitlin,
    I really enjoyed reading your blog post about the notion of "reinventing the wheel." I use that term often when referring to teachers' participation in online communities (social media sites) and how, rather than having to reinvent the wheel, they can find successful projects/ideas/resources that other teachers have already tried and endorsed. But, I think that you are definitely right - it is about time to reinvent the wheel for education and think of all of the ways that technology can help do that.

    ReplyDelete
  2. While I absolutely agree with what you have pointed out, Caitlin, I feel that a lot of schools are already implementing technology into their programs and curriculum. I think it is fantastic and agree that buying new pieces of technology help the classroom further their resource opportunities. However, like you said, in our, "rapidly changing future," how do we keep up? Buying up to 180 iPads for teachers and up to 200 iPads for students plus computers, how long will that item be what the students should be learning to use and research on? I worry that technology changes so swiftly that once we spend hundreds of thousands of dollars on the "newest" product, the new iDevice will have entered the market.

    ReplyDelete
  3. By the way, I really enjoyed reading your blog and looks like you put a lot of work into it :)

    ReplyDelete